Geneva, NY, is home to some fabulous ice cream shops – and who doesn’t love ice cream on a hot summer day? If you’re out and about fishing, boating, or shopping, ice cream will be the perfect sweet treat for you and your family before heading back to Belhurst Castle, just a few minutes away from all of the best ice cream shops in Geneva, NY. 

The 2 Best Ice Cream Shops in Geneva, NY

There are several ice cream shops in the Geneva area, but we want to tell you about the two very best ice cream shops around. These ice cream shops have every flavor you could ever dream of. So bring the whole gang and satisfy your sweet tooth when you visit the ice cream shops in Geneva, NY!

Mr. Twistee’s

Mr. Twistee’s serves a variety of ice cream, and lots of the flavors are friendly to those with dietary restrictions – gluten-free, lactose-free, and sugar-free. Choose from hard ice cream, soft ice cream sherbert, Italian ice, Bavarian Vanilla, and specials! Everyone will find something that they love at Mr. Twistee’s. Stop by any day of the week between noon and 10 p.m. 

Geneva Gelato Cafe

The delicious gelato at Geneva Gelato in Cafe is made in Italy and perfected in Geneva. The artisans at this cafe work tirelessly to perfect all of their delicious flavors, all made with fresh, local ingredients, so you know you’re getting the best quality. Head to their website to view hours of operation before visiting for some yummy gelato!

Picture of rental near ice cream shops in Geneva.Geneva, NY Hotels: Belhurst Castle

The beautiful Belhurst Castle is the perfect place to stay when you’re looking for a hotel in Geneva around the Finger Lakes. You’ll be amazed at the architecture of the castle and our other two hotels on the property. Whether you want a romantic weekend getaway or fun for the whole family, we have everything you need at Belhurst to have a memorable experience! Enjoy dining at our restaurants, wine and craft beer, and much more. Book one of the guest rooms in one of our three hotels today by calling us at 315-781-0201 Ext 2.