Stonecutter’s Tavern

Casual pub-style food and a fun family atmosphere are the center of Stonecutters Tavern.

Enjoy our own craft beer, Mabel’s Oat Soda Co., have a cocktail at the sunken bar and take in the most idyllic views of Seneca Lake and savor daily food and appetizer specials from our kitchen. Sit back, relax and enjoy great food and great friends at Stonecutters Tavern.

Hours: 11 am – 9:00 pm

Stonecutters Tavern logo.


dessert tray

Life’s too short. Why wait? Eat dessert first!
Select something delectable off of our famous dessert tray.


Smoked Gouda Dip
A warm dip of artichokes, spinach and smoked Gouda served with two toasted naan breads 16.95
Paired perfectly with our Belhurst Chardonnay

Layered nachos loaded with queso, roasted corn & black bean salsa, pico de gallo, sour cream and drizzled with chipotle ranch 12.95 Add Chicken 8.95

Daily Flatbread
Please ask your server for today’s daily naan flatbread special! 13.95

Mozzarella Wedges
Breaded and fried fresh mozzarella served with house marinara sauce and topped with fresh basil 14.95

Calamari Fritti
Tender breaded calamari tentacles and rings tossed with fresh tomato relish, assorted olives and pepperoncini rings. Finished with a roasted garlic aïoli and shredded Asiago cheese 18.95

French Onion Soup
Caramelized medley of onions in a savory steak and sherry broth. Baked with brioche crostini, Provolone and Swiss cheese 8.95
Paired perfectly with our Mabel’s Oat Soda Co. Porter

Seafood Chowder
Creamy chowder of shrimp, crab, white fish and pancetta topped with fresh scallions
cup 9.95, bowl 11.95, bread bowl 13.95
Paired perfectly with our Belhurst Dry Riesling

Beef and beer chili using our own Mabel’s Oat Soda Co. craft beer, topped with Cheddar and scallions
cup 6.95, bowl 9.95, bread bowl 11.95

Soup du Jour
cup 5.95, bowl 7.95
Make it a meal! A bowl of soup and a pint of beer!


Add grilled or fried chicken to any salad for 8.95. Add grilled shrimp (5) to any salad for 8.95

Strawberry & Spinach Salad
Tender baby spinach topped with fresh strawberries, bacon, candied pecans, crumbled Gorgonzola and red onion. Dressed in a raspberry vinaigrette 15.95
Paired perfectly with our Belhurst Carrie Blush

Castle Garden Salad
Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, sliced cucumber, carrots and red onion. Finished with choice of dressing 12.95

Statesmen Steakhouse Salad
Steakhouse marinated USDA choice beef tenderloin medallions over romaine and mixed field greens with crispy Tabasco onions, crumbled Gorgonzola cheese and grape tomatoes. Finished with a herbed red wine vinaigrette 22.95
Paired perfectly with our Belhurst Cabernet Sauvignon 
Belhurst is a proud supporter of Hobart & William Smith!

Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with shaved Parmesan and Asiago cheese, grape tomatoes, garlic-herb croutons and creamy Caesar
dressing 13.95

Southwest Chicken Salad
Mixed greens, roasted corn, black beans, pico, Cheddar, grilled chicken and crispy tortilla strips.  Finished with a chipotle ranch dressing 19.95


All selections come with a dill spear and choice of kettle chips or balsamic dressed field greens.
Upgrade to French fries or onion rings for 3.95 or salad du jour for 2.95.

Stonecutters Steak sandwich
Thin sliced, slow roasted beef, sautéed mushrooms and horseradish mayo on a hoagie roll served with a cup of herb scented beef au jus for dipping 21.95

Grilled Chicken Pesto Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, basil pesto mayo, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, lettuce, sliced tomato and red onion served on a Kaiser roll 17.95 

Roasted Turkey Panini
Slow roasted turkey breast, cranberry mayo, Brie and spinach on a toasted ciabatta panini 18.95
Paired perfectly with our Mabel’s Oat Soda Co. Honey Blonde 

Mushroom Swiss Burger
8-ounce burger patty topped with sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and Truffle Aioli on a garlic buttered Kaiser roll 19.95

Red’s Reuben  
Grilled corned beef, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese and 1000 Island dressing served on grilled marble rye 19.95

Sweet and Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwich 
Fried chicken breast, sweet and spicy Gochujang sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, and basil mayo served on Garlic toasted Sourdough bread 17.95

House-made falafel, naan bread, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, feta cheese and tzatziki sauce 16.95

French Onion Pub Filet
Filet medallions, Provolone and french onion demi glaze on a garlic butter toasted ciabatta 21.95

Castle Burger
Hand pressed ground 8-ounce steak burger, New York State cheddar, green leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, red onion and mayo served on a Kaiser roll 18.95
Add bacon 2.95. Add mushrooms 1.75, Add grilled onions 1.50
Paired perfectly with our Mabel’s Oat Soda Co. NE IPA 

Crab Cake BLT
Fried crab cake topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce on a toasted Kaiser roll 22.95

Cuban Sandwich
Slow roasted pork, capicola, sliced pickles, Swiss cheese and whole grain mustard served on pressed ciabatta 19.95

Beef on Weck
Thin sliced, slow roasted beef, Swiss cheese and horseradish mayo topped with crispy onions on kimmelweck bun 21.95

Monte Cristo
Smoked Black Forest ham and Swiss cheese on French toast bread with raspberry jam and dejon mustard 21.95


Honey Blonde




Mabel’s Oat Soda Co. craft beers are also available for tastings and for sale in our Belhurst Wine & Gift Shop! We carry Pepsi Cola products, Fresh Brewed Ice Tea, Saratoga Sparkling Water and Lemonade

We kindly request no separate checks on parties of four or more. A 20% gratuity will be added on checks of parties of six or more. Split plate fee $2. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, or shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.